Is my SEO agency ripping me off? 7 signs to check (2026)

Seven warning signs to check, based on 63 buyer accounts. Twelve reported missing work and eight said they couldn't verify reports.

7 signs point to it: invisible work, unverifiable numbers, off-topic links, agency-held accounts, unapproved profile edits, no named worker, and rankings for terms you don't sell. Of 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving in 2024–2026, 12 said agreed work wasn't done, 8 couldn't verify reports and 5 struggled to get accounts back. One sign proves little; several together justify an independent review.

The 7 signs

SignHow common in our researchHow to check
1. You can't see what changed on your siteAgreed work not done: 12 of 63Check site changes and new pages
2. Report numbers aren't in your own accountsReports couldn't be checked: 8 of 63Compare the report with Search Console
3. Links from unrelated or very weak sitesTrust or link risk: 7 of 63Ask for every link placed; see off-page SEO evidence
4. The agency owns your domain, website or profileHandover trouble: 5 of 63Check which accounts the agency controls
5. Business Profile edits you didn't approveTwo accountsCheck Business Profile access
6. No one says who does the workCapacity complaints: 4 of 63Ask who works on your account and how many clients they handle
7. Rankings for terms you don't care aboutStrategy didn't fit: 12 of 63Find which keywords bring clicks

Counts are from 63 businesses that left or considered leaving their agency; one business can show several signs.

What buyers in the same spot found

  • A roofing company asked this exact question. It was paying $5,000 a month for one blog post a quarter, and its report didn't match Search Console (source).
  • A buyer ended a contract on the spot when the agency planned to publish articles linking to a competitor (source).
  • Another found links on sites with authority scores of 1 to 3 and asked for an indefinite pause (source).
  • A local business said its agency changed the opening date on its Business Profile from about one year ago to about ten without asking (source).
  • On a one-year contract, the #1 ranking an agency reported was for a keyword the owner didn't care about (source).

What to do next

Check your accounts before anything else: if you own them, you can leave whenever you choose. Then ask the agency in writing for a dated list of work and the full link list. If the answers don't match what you're paying for, see should I fire my SEO agency?

FAQ

Yes. Paid link schemes break Google's spam policies, and you can't judge links you can't see. One buyer found links on sites with authority scores of 1–3, asked for an indefinite pause, then reported 8 charges of $300 (source).

How many warning signs justify a review?

One sign proves little; 3 or more justify an independent review. Of 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving, 32 named 2 or more reasons.

Sources