Why do businesses fire their SEO agency? (2026)
In 63 public buyer accounts, the top reasons for leaving or considering leaving an SEO agency were weak business results, missed work and cost.
- buyer accounts, 2024–2026
- 63
- had already left
- 43
- cited weak business results
- 40%
- said agreed work wasn't done
- 19%
The most common reasons buyers cited for leaving or considering leaving their SEO agency were weak business results (40%), missing or poor work (33%) and cost relative to return (30%). That's from 63 public buyer accounts in 2024–2026; among the 43 who had already left, those 3 reasons tied at 14 accounts each, and all 4 who quit within 2 months blamed missing work (data).
The reasons, by share
| Reason | Accounts (of 63) | Share | Of the 43 who left | What buyers described |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Results never reached leads or revenue | 25 | 40% | 14 | Rankings or traffic flat or falling, or rising without calls, orders or sales |
| Promised work not delivered, or poor work | 21 | 33% | 14 | No changes to the site, missed tasks, weak content or links |
| Cost against return | 19 | 30% | 14 | The fee was more than the work or the results justified |
| Reports and communication | 14 | 22% | 6 | Reports they couldn't check; slow replies or none |
| Strategy didn't fit the business | 12 | 19% | 7 | Wrong market, keywords or audience, or an outdated approach |
| In-house SEO or business change | 10 | 16% | 9 | A team member or tool could take over, or business needs or budgets shifted |
| Trust, link risk or account control | 7 | 11% | 3 | Suspect links, changed listings, doubts about honesty |
Source: coded data, 63 accounts. One account can name several reasons, so the shares add up to more than 100%: 31 accounts named one reason and 32 named two or more. The 20 accounts that hadn't left yet had either given notice (4) or were considering it (16).
What the top three looked like
Results. Ten of the 25 results complaints were about leads rather than rankings: four buyers saw rankings or reports improve while calls and orders didn't, and six said leads, calls or sales were plainly too few. An IT services buyer reached first place for its target keyword and had no paying work from it after seven months (source). A window cleaning company paid over $500 a month for nearly two years and got one or two leads (source).
Delivery. Apart from cost, the most common specific complaint was agreed work not being done: 12 of 63 accounts (19%). A real estate buyer said nothing had been done in 45 days (source). A UK B2B company checked its website's revision history against the agency's report and said the listed work hadn't happened (source).
Cost. Cost was rarely the only reason: 16 of the 19 accounts paired it with another problem, most often weak delivery (8). A small business paying $2,550 a month plus a setup fee said four months passed with no changes to its site and no articles (source).
Reasons by time with the agency
19 buyers said how long they had worked with the agency (data).
| Time with the agency | Accounts | Cited results | Cited delivery |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 2 months | 4 | 0 | 4 |
| 3–6 months | 7 | 5 | 3 |
| 7–12 months | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| Over 12 months | 5 | 4 | 0 |
All four buyers who left within two months did so because work wasn't done or was poor; none blamed results. Results were the leading reason among buyers who reported working with the agency for at least three months (12 of 15). Eleven of the 19 left, gave notice or considered leaving within six months. (data)
In-house SEO and business changes
Ten accounts cited taking SEO in-house or a change within the business. Nine had already left. Eight accounts specifically cited a person or tool that could take over. A three-person team replaced its agency with two tools costing about $75 a month (source).
AI search in the 2026 accounts
Four accounts left or considered leaving over AI search, either because the agency didn't cover it or because AI visibility didn't improve, and all four were posted in 2026. A SaaS team switched to a provider that handles both SEO and AI search so it wouldn't have to coordinate two agencies (source). A product team ended its contract because the agency kept working on keywords rather than AI search, and moved the work in-house (source).
What happened after notice
Nine accounts (14%) ran into problems once they decided to leave. Five had trouble getting the website, domain or hosting back, and four disputed charges, refunds or notice periods. One buyer said the old agency paused hosting of the website at the exit, and got the site back later (source). Another asked for an indefinite pause, then reported eight $300 charges; the agency disputed that a pause had been agreed (source).
These handover problems are counted separately from the reasons above.
How to check your own agency
- Compare what changed on your site with what the reports list: check WordPress changes and check new pages.
- Compare the report with Search Console, number by number.
- Find which keywords bring clicks, then follow them to calls and forms with GA4 key events.
- Check which accounts the agency controls.
- Agree a review month: see how long to give an SEO agency.
Method
- Source: public English-language Reddit posts and comments dated 1 January 2024 to 22 November 2026. The latest included account is from 13 November 2026. (data)
- Included: a business describing its own decision about an external SEO agency or outsourced SEO team: already left (43), gave notice (4) or clearly considering leaving (16).
- Excluded: posts by agencies or sellers, second-hand stories, general complaints with no decision, and requests for recommendations only.
- Counting: one row per buyer and experience. Each row is coded for every reason the buyer stated, and shares use 63 as the denominator. Time with the agency is as the buyer stated it (19 of 63 did). (data)
- Not in the percentages: 4 accounts from X, and 13 accounts from a separate 2022–2023 search, where results, delivery and cost were also the top three (7 of 13 each). (data)
- Limits: Reddit's search and the words people use shape what can be found. Accounts are self-reported and weren't checked with the agencies. Satisfied clients and those who left quietly are under-represented. The shares describe this sample. Meridian is an SEO agency and publishes the coding and sources so readers can check the findings.
FAQ
How long do businesses give an SEO agency before leaving?
Of the 19 buyers who said how long they stayed, 11 left, gave notice or considered leaving within 6 months; all 4 who left within 2 months cited missing work, and 12 of 15 buyers who reported working with the agency for at least three months cited results (data).
Was taking SEO in-house a reason buyers considered leaving?
Eight of 63 buyers specifically cited an in-house person or tool that could take over. Seven of those eight had already left the agency (data). One 3-person team replaced its agency with 2 tools for about $75 a month (source).
Sources
- Coded data, one row per account with its source link: seo-agency-exit-reasons-2024-2026.csv and the codebook.
- The original posts are linked in the text above and in the data file.




