How to check whether your SEO agency has published new pages
4 checks in 20 minutes show whether pages your SEO agency reported are live and indexed. One buyer found 2 pages indexed and 0 of the agency's posts.
4 checks in 20 minutes show whether each page your agency reported is live and in Google: sitemap, CMS dates, the Pages report and URL Inspection. One buyer found only 2 of the site's pages indexed and 0 of the agency's blog posts. 12 of 63 businesses that left their agency in 2024–2026 said agreed work wasn't done. Needs Search Console access; free.
You end up with a list of every page the agency reported, marked as live or missing, and indexed or not.
Step 1: Collect the URLs the agency reported
Go through the last three monthly reports and copy every new or updated page they mention into one list. If a report says "5 blog posts" without URLs, ask for the URLs before you go further.
Step 2: Look for them in your sitemap
Open your sitemap: /sitemap.xml, /sitemap_index.xml (Yoast, Rank Math) or /wp-sitemap.xml (WordPress without an SEO plugin). Shopify uses /sitemap.xml. Find each URL and note its lastmod date where shown.
Step 3: Check the publish dates in your CMS
In your website's admin, sort pages and posts by date. Pages published in the months you paid for should be there, with the dates the report gives.
Step 4: Read the indexed count in Search Console
Go to Indexing → Pages. The chart shows how many pages Google has indexed over time. If the agency says it published 20 pages in three months, the indexed count usually moves too. Open Why pages aren't indexed to see if new URLs are listed there.
Step 5: Inspect each reported URL
Paste each URL into the URL Inspection bar at the top of Search Console. "URL is on Google" means it's indexed. "URL is not on Google" comes with a reason and the last crawl date.
Step 6: Record what you found
For each URL, note: exists (yes/no), in sitemap, indexed, date. Send the list to the agency with your questions.
What it takes
About 20 minutes for 20 URLs. You need Search Console access (any permission level) and a login to your website. Free.
What the result means
- The page doesn't exist: it wasn't delivered.
- It exists but hasn't been indexed for weeks: a quality or technical problem worth raising; the Page indexing report gives the reason.
- It's indexed but has no impressions: it targets searches people don't make, or it can't compete yet. Check it again in a month.
One buyer looked in Search Console and found only two of the site's pages indexed, and none of the blog posts the agency had published (source).
If your agency does this for you
Ask for every published URL in the monthly report, with its index status from Search Console. It takes them minutes.
Good to know
- New pages can take days or weeks to be indexed, and Google doesn't index every page it finds.
- A sitemap lists what the site offers to Google, not what Google has indexed.
- Changes to existing pages are a separate check: see how to check what your SEO agency changed on WordPress.
- Days to weeks, and Google doesn't index every page (Google). If a reported page still isn't indexed after several weeks, inspect it: one buyer found only 2 of the site's pages indexed and 0 of the agency's posts (source).
- Usually at /sitemap.xml. Yoast and Rank Math use /sitemap_index.xml, and WordPress without an SEO plugin uses /wp-sitemap.xml.
Sources
- Search Console Help: Page indexing report and URL Inspection tool
- Meridian buyer research: Why do businesses fire their SEO agency?




