Should I fire my SEO agency? How to decide (2026)
Use your agency's deliverables, lead trends and account access to decide whether to keep the agency, renegotiate or leave.
Fire your SEO agency if it can't show what it changed, can't explain flat leads after the agreed review date, or won't give you owner access. Of 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving in 2024–2026, 12 said agreed work wasn't done, and all 4 who quit within 2 months blamed missing work, not slow results. Slow results alone aren't a reason while the work is visible and the review date hasn't passed.
Leave now if…
- You can't see the work. No changes to the site, no new pages and no links for a month or more after kickoff. Agreed work not being done came up in 12 of 63 accounts.
- The numbers can't be checked. Report figures don't appear in your own Search Console or Analytics, and the agency won't say where they come from (8 of 63).
- The agency holds your accounts. It owns the domain, website or Business Profile and won't transfer them (5 of 63 hit this when leaving).
- You find changes you didn't approve, such as links on unrelated sites or edits to your Business Profile (7 of 63 raised trust or link risk).
- No one answers. Questions go unanswered for weeks (7 of 63).
Give it more time if…
- The work in the contract is visible on your site, month by month.
- Early signals are moving: more pages indexed, more impressions for the services you sell.
- The review month you agreed hasn't arrived. 31% of buyers in our research on how businesses choose an agency set one before signing; if you didn't, set one now.
A 10-question check
Answer yes or no. Three or more "no" answers is a reason to renegotiate in writing; six or more is a reason to plan your exit.
- Can you list what changed on your site last month?
- Can you find the report's main numbers in your own accounts?
- Do the searches you rank for bring clicks?
- Do those clicks lead to calls, forms or sales you can count?
- Do you know who does the work on your account?
- Do you get a reply within two working days?
- Do you own your domain, website, Search Console, Analytics and Business Profile?
- Can you see every link the agency built?
- Did you agree a review date and what should move by then?
- Does the plan still match the services and places you sell?
What buyers in the same spot did
- An IT services buyer ranked first for its target keyword, had no paying work from it after seven months, and ended the contract (source).
- A solo law practice found nearly half of the first month's tasks undone without warning; when new promises were also missed, it left and booked calls with other agencies (source).
- Leaving isn't risk-free: one company's rankings mostly vanished under a third agency, and it went back to the second (source).
How to check
- Check what your SEO agency changed on your WordPress site
- Compare your SEO report with Google Search Console
- Check which of your accounts your SEO agency controls
What to do next
If you're staying, write down what must change and by when, and review it on that date. If you're leaving, secure your accounts before you give notice: see how to fire your SEO agency without losing rankings.
FAQ
Is it normal for an SEO agency to take 6 months to show results?
For leads, often yes; for visible work, no. In our research, 12 of 15 buyers who reported working with an agency for at least three months cited results, but all 4 who left within 2 months did so because work wasn't being done. Expect changed pages in month 1 and more indexed pages and impressions by month 3.
What should I do before telling my agency I'm leaving?
Secure owner access to your domain, hosting, website, Search Console, Analytics and Business Profile first. 5 of 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving had trouble getting the website, domain or hosting back, and 4 of 63 disputed charges or notice periods.
Sources
- Meridian buyer research: Why do businesses fire their SEO agency? (63 buyer accounts, 2024–2026)
- The buyer accounts above are linked to the original public posts.




