How to compare your SEO report with Google Search Console, number by number
Match every SEO report number to Search Console or GA4 in 45 minutes. One report showed 400+ indexed pages where Search Console had 43.
In 45 minutes and 6 steps, match each number in your SEO report to Search Console or GA4 and see which gaps need an answer. 8 of 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving their agency in 2024–2026 couldn't verify its reports; one showed 400+ indexed pages where Search Console had 43. Needs Search Console and GA4 access; free.
You end up with a table of the report's numbers next to your own, with the gaps that need an explanation marked.
Step 1: Write down each number in the report
For each figure, note what it claims to measure, its source, its unit and its date range. Report figures often say "traffic" or "visibility" without saying whether that means clicks, sessions or users.
Step 2: Open Search Console for the same dates
Go to Performance → Search results. Set the date range to match the report and keep the search type as Web. Note total clicks and impressions, and the top pages.
Step 3: Check the indexed page count
Go to Indexing → Pages and note the number of indexed pages. Compare it with any "pages optimised" or "pages indexed" figure in the report.
Step 4: Check organic visits and leads in GA4
In GA4, go to Reports → Acquisition → Traffic acquisition, set the same dates and look at the Organic Search row: sessions and key events (form submissions, calls). GA4's Organic Search includes Bing and other search engines; Search Console covers Google only.
Step 5: Filter by the places you serve
Add a country filter in Search Console (+ Add filter → Country) and in GA4. Growth from countries or cities you don't serve doesn't bring customers.
Step 6: Send the agency a table of gaps
| Report says | Search Console / GA4 says | Same unit? | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|---|
| e.g. 13,000 organic visitors | 403 clicks | No (GA4 users vs GSC clicks) | Which tool and which metric is this? |
| e.g. 400+ pages indexed | 43 indexed | Yes | Where does 400 come from? |
What it takes
About 45 minutes. You need Search Console access and GA4 access with at least Viewer permission. Free.
What the result means
| Report figure | Closest match | Why they differ |
|---|---|---|
| Traffic or visitors | GA4 sessions or users in Organic Search | GA4 includes other search engines; users and sessions count differently from clicks |
| Clicks | Search Console clicks | Should be close if dates and search type match |
| Keywords ranking | Search Console queries with impressions | Rank trackers check a chosen list; Search Console shows real searches |
| Pages indexed or optimised | Search Console indexed pages | "Optimised" or "crawled" isn't the same as indexed |
| Leads | GA4 key events and your own records | Only counts what's tracked; check against your inbox and phone |
A gap in units is normal. A gap in the same unit for the same dates needs an explanation. One roofing company's report listed more than 400 indexed pages and about 13,000 organic users; Search Console showed 43 indexed pages and 403 clicks for the same period (source).
If your agency does this for you
Ask that every number in the monthly report names its tool, metric and date range, and that clicks and indexed pages come straight from Search Console.
Good to know
- Search Console data is usually two to three days behind and keeps 16 months.
- Search Console leaves out some rare queries for privacy, so query totals are lower than the overall total.
- Clicks and impressions for the same dates and search type should be close. Indexed pages should match too: 400+ in a report against 43 in Search Console, as one roofer saw in 2024, isn't a counting difference (source).
- Search Console leaves out some rare queries to protect privacy, so the query rows add up to less than the chart total (Google).
Sources
- Search Console Help: Performance report and Page indexing report
- Meridian buyer research: Why do businesses fire their SEO agency?




