How long should I give an SEO agency before judging results? (2026)

Review your SEO agency in stages, from visible work in month one to indexing and impressions by month three and enquiries later.

Give an SEO agency 1 month to show work, 3 months to move indexing and impressions, and 6–9 months to move leads, with the review month agreed up front. Of 19 buyers in our research who said how long they stayed, 11 left, gave notice or considered leaving within 6 months. 22 of 71 buyers choosing an agency set a review point before signing.

Judge each stage by its own signal

StageSignalWhere to lookWarning sign
Month 1Work delivered: audit, priorities, first changesReport, your siteNo list of work, no access requests
Months 2–3More pages indexed, more impressions for your servicesSearch ConsoleNothing new indexed, impressions flat
Months 4–6Non-branded clicks to the pages that matterSearch ConsoleClicks only from your brand name
Months 6–9Calls, forms and sales from organic searchGA4, your recordsClicks rise, leads don't

Reasons by time with the agency

From 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving, 19 said how long they had worked with the agency:

Time with the agencyAccountsCited resultsCited missing or poor work
Under 2 months404
3–6 months753
7–12 months330
Over 12 months540

All four buyers who left within two months cited missing or poor work. At three months or later, results were the most commonly cited reason.

Review points buyers set

  • A locksmith accepted 6 months to show progress, judged by real leads, not ticked-off tasks (source).
  • A construction company planned to check after 6–9 months for 5 inspection bookings and 1–2 sales a month (source).
  • A UK flooring firm paying £600 a month weighed cutting its 3-month review short (source).
  • A moving company noted customers book 4–6 weeks ahead, so leads lag clicks by that much (source).

What to do next

Write the review month and the signal for each stage into the agreement, and record a baseline before work starts. If you're already 3 months in, see no SEO results after 3 months.

FAQ

Is 3 months too early to judge an SEO agency?

Too early for leads, not for work. A UK flooring firm paying £600 a month had 5 local terms at positions 35–45 after about 3 months and couldn't tell whether 2 quote requests came from SEO (source). Judge month 3 by indexing and impressions.

Should the review month be written into the contract?

Yes. 22 of 71 buyers set a review point before signing, and 1 family business asked for quantifiable targets with a plan if they were missed, while accepting there'd be no guarantee (source).

Sources