What do businesses look for when hiring an SEO agency? (2026)
Across 71 buyer accounts (2024–2026): fee and scope 80%, verifiable results 73%, an explained plan 69%. Reputation and referrals came last at 17%.
- buyer accounts, 2024–2026
- 71
- checked fee and scope
- 80%
- wanted results they could verify
- 73%
- named reputation or referrals
- 17%
Businesses hiring an SEO agency check 3 things most: a clear fee and scope (80%), results they can verify (73%) and a plan the agency can explain (69%). That's from 71 public buyer accounts in 2024–2026; reputation and referrals came last at 17%, and 56 of 71 buyers named 3 to 5 criteria (data).
The criteria, by share
| Criterion | Accounts (of 71) | Share | What buyers asked for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fee, scope and contract | 57 | 80% | A budget, what the fee covers, expected return, trial or exit terms |
| Results they can verify | 52 | 73% | Real case studies, checkable rankings, leads or revenue |
| An explained plan | 49 | 69% | A diagnosis, priorities and the actual technical, content and link work |
| Reporting and communication | 37 | 52% | Update rhythm, visible delivery, KPIs, reviews |
| Industry and location fit | 36 | 51% | Knows the industry, local market, site type and audience |
| Guarantees, risk and ownership | 24 | 34% | A stance on ranking guarantees, link risk, conflicts, account ownership |
| Working model and effort | 24 | 34% | Agency vs consultant vs freelancer, and how much work falls on the buyer |
| Reputation and references | 12 | 17% | Referrals, reviews, background checks, credentials |
Source: coded data, 71 accounts. One account can name several criteria.
Inside the top three
Fee and scope. 45 of 71 buyers (63%) asked for a clear budget and what it covers. A construction company was quoted $2,800 for 20 hours a month or $3,800 for 30, and planned to check after 6–9 months for 5 inspection bookings and 1–2 sales a month (source).
Verifiable results. 30 of 71 judged results by leads, calls or sales, 30 by rankings, traffic or Search Console, and 14 used both. An ecommerce owner with about 15 staff wanted case studies from businesses its size and reports tied to revenue (source).
An explained plan. 23 of 71 (32%) wanted specific pages and content, and 16 (23%) wanted a diagnosis before a roadmap. A sole trader compared AUD 600, 1,129.20 and 2,600 quotes and trusted the dearest because it listed 32 pages, KPIs and a timeline (source).
Guarantees: most buyers were wary
9 of 71 (13%) questioned or rejected ranking or timing guarantees; 3 of 71 (4%) asked for one. One family business asked for measurable targets and a plan if they were missed, while accepting there'd be no guarantee (source).
What this means if you're hiring
Ask for the fee in units you can compare (hours, pages, links, locations), results you can check, and the first 90 days in writing. See 12 questions to ask an SEO agency, what should be in an SEO contract and what SEO agencies cost.
Method
- Source: public English-language Reddit posts and comments dated 1 January 2024 to 22 November 2026; the latest included account is from 16 November 2026. (data)
- Included: buyers looking for or comparing agencies (24), replacing or reviewing one (23), reviewing a current one (16), satisfied with one (5), who had just signed (2) or were screening (1).
- Counted: a criterion only when the buyer used it to choose; one row per buyer and decision; shares use 71 as the denominator.
- Not in the percentages: 7 accounts from X and 17 from a 2022–2023 search, where fee and scope (16 of 17) and the plan (14 of 17) also led. (data)
- Limits: self-reported, not checked with the agencies; Reddit search and wording shape what's found. Meridian is an SEO agency; the data is published so you can check it.
FAQ
Do businesses care more about price or results?
Both, almost equally: 80% asked about fee and scope and 73% about verifiable results, across 71 buyer accounts in 2024–2026. Most named 3 to 5 criteria, so price alone rarely decided.
How important are referrals when choosing an SEO agency?
Less than you might expect: reputation and references came last, at 12 of 71 accounts (17%), in our data.
Sources
- Coded data: seo-agency-selection-criteria-2024-2026.csv and codebook
- Companion research: Why do businesses fire their SEO agency?
- The buyer accounts above are linked to the original public posts.




