My SEO report doesn't match Google Search Console: who's right? (2026)
Reports and Search Console often count different things, but same-unit gaps aren't normal: one report showed 400+ indexed pages, Search Console 43.
Usually both: reports count sessions or tracked keywords, Search Console counts clicks and indexed pages. A same-unit gap is a red flag: one roofer paying $5,000 a month saw 400+ indexed pages in its report and 43 in Search Console. 8 of 63 businesses that left or weighed leaving their agency in 2024–2026 said its reports couldn't be checked.
Why the numbers can differ legitimately
| Report says | Closest number you can check | Why they differ |
|---|---|---|
| Traffic, visitors | GA4 sessions or users in Organic Search | GA4 includes Bing and others and counts visits, not clicks |
| Clicks | Search Console clicks | Should be close if the dates and search type match |
| Keywords ranking | Search Console queries | A rank tracker checks a chosen list; Search Console shows real searches |
| Pages optimised or crawled | Search Console indexed pages | Crawled or "optimised" isn't the same as indexed |
| Leads | GA4 key events, your inbox and phone | Only what's tracked gets counted |
When a gap is a warning sign
- The same metric for the same dates is far apart.
- The report can't say which tool a number comes from.
- Growth comes from countries or cities you don't serve. One local service business found its reported growth was mostly from India (source).
- Every chart goes up, but calls and forms don't.
What buyers in the same spot found
- The roofing company, paying $5,000 a month, saw about 13,000 organic users in the report and 403 clicks in Search Console for the same period. Calls and forms hadn't grown, and the report even listed law-related pages (source).
- A renovation company rarely saw itself in search results while the agency said results were good (source).
- After about nine months, an Australian buyer said progress kept being explained by algorithm updates it couldn't verify (source).
Reports that couldn't be checked came up in 8 of 63 accounts in our research.
How to check
Follow how to compare your SEO report with Google Search Console, number by number. It ends with a table of gaps to send the agency.
What to do next
Send the table and ask for the tool, metric and date range behind each number. Agree that clicks and indexed pages in future reports come straight from Search Console. If the answers don't close the gaps, that's a reason to reconsider the agency.
FAQ
Why does GA4 show more organic traffic than Search Console clicks?
GA4's Organic Search includes Bing and other engines and counts sessions or users; Search Console counts Google clicks only. A gap is normal, a 30-fold one deserves a question: one roofer's report showed about 13,000 organic users against 403 Search Console clicks (source).
How much history does Search Console keep?
16 months of Performance data (Google), with the latest days still filling in. Compare complete months, and export before the 16 months run out.
Sources
- Search Console Help: Performance report and Page indexing report
- Meridian buyer research: Why do businesses fire their SEO agency?
- The buyer accounts above are linked to the original public posts.




