How to record an SEO baseline before a new agency starts

A 6-section baseline sheet in about an hour: clicks, indexed pages, top 10 pages, rankings, leads and links, dated before the new agency starts.

One dated sheet with 6 sections (clicks, indexed pages, top 10 pages, local rankings, leads by source, links) takes about an hour and anchors every later report. Without one, a UK flooring firm paying £600 a month couldn't tell whether 2 quote requests came from SEO (source).

You end up with the numbers both you and the new agency will compare against at every review.

Step 1: Search Console clicks

From Performance → Search results, record clicks and impressions for the last 3 months and the same months last year. Split them into branded and non-branded with a regex filter; see how to split branded and non-branded clicks.

Step 2: Indexed pages

From Indexing → Pages, record the number of indexed pages and the main reasons pages aren't indexed.

Step 3: Key pages

List your 10 most important pages (services, locations, top products). For each, record clicks for the last 3 months and the top query.

Step 4: Rankings across your area

For local businesses, run a grid check of your main services; see how to check your Google Maps ranking across your service area. For others, record the positions of 10 to 20 non-branded queries from Search Console.

Step 5: Leads by source

Count last quarter's enquiries, calls and sales from organic search, using GA4 key events and your own records. Note how each is counted, so the method stays the same later.

From Search Console's Links report, record the number of linking sites and export the top linking sites.

Step 7: Date it and share it

Save the sheet with today's date, share it with the new agency at kickoff, and agree which of these numbers you'll review, and when.

What it takes

About an hour. You need Search Console and GA4 access, and your own lead records. Free.

What the result means

Without a baseline, neither you nor the agency can show what changed. In our research, one business whose rankings mostly vanished under a new agency could tell because it had tracked the same keywords before the switch, and moved back to the previous agency (source). Another owner had two quote requests and a contact in the agency's report but couldn't tell which came from SEO (source).

If your agency does this for you

Ask for the baseline sheet in the first two weeks, with each number's source, and confirm the review month in writing. See how long to give an SEO agency.

Good to know

  • Search Console keeps 16 months, so record last year's numbers now.
  • If you're leaving an agency, export everything first; the baseline is built from those exports.
  • Non-branded clicks, indexed pages and leads by source; rankings alone mislead. Of 71 buyers choosing an agency in 2024–2026, 30 judged results by leads, calls or sales and 30 by rankings or traffic.
  • 16 months, the most Search Console keeps (Google), so you can compare the same months year on year.

Sources