What questions should I ask an SEO agency before hiring? (2026)

12 questions to ask an SEO agency, with good and weak answers. From 71 buyers: 80% checked fee and scope, 69% the plan, 31% set a review date.

Ask 12 questions before you sign, starting with who does the work, what changes in the first 90 days, and how results tie to calls or sales. They match what 71 buyers checked in 2024–2026: 80% asked about fee and scope, 69% about the plan, 31% set a review date.

The 12 questions

QuestionWhy askGood answerWalk away if
1. Who will do the work, and how many clients do they handle?One buyer's analyst handled about 30 accounts (source)A named person and a number"The team" with no names
2. What changes in the first 90 days, month by month?16 of 71 wanted a diagnosis before a roadmapDated deliverables"We'll start optimising"
3. Which searches will you target, and why?Rankings for terms you don't sell bring nothingSearches tied to your services and areasA keyword count
4. How will results tie to calls, forms or sales?30 of 71 judged results by leadsA tracking plan using your accountsRankings only
5. What will the monthly report contain?23 of 71 wanted reports they could verifyWork done with URLs, plus outcomesA chart pack
6. When do we review progress, and against what?22 of 71 set a review pointA month and a signal for each stage"SEO takes time"
7. How do you get links, and will you list every one?9 of 71 cared about link qualityA full list with how each was obtainedNo list
8. Do you guarantee rankings?9 of 71 questioned guaranteesNo, with what they will commit toA promised position or date
9. Who owns the accounts and content?4 of 71 asked for everything in their nameYour business, the agency as userThe agency
10. What's the notice period, and can I pause?Buyers met 30- and 60-day noticeA clear number and process"It's in the terms"
11. Can I speak to a client like me?11 of 71 wanted referencesA similar business, same marketLogos only
12. Do you work for my direct competitors?1 lawn care owner checked this (source)A straight yes or noEvasion

Source: counts from 71 buyer accounts, 2024–2026.

Answers that should make you walk away

A guaranteed #1 or a page-one date: as Google's own guidance puts it, "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google). Also: no named person, links they won't list, or accounts set up in the agency's name.

What buyers learned the hard way

  • After a polished sales pitch, one buyer's account went to junior staff with generic monthly reports; next time they wanted 1 named lead throughout (source).
  • An ecommerce owner with about 15 staff doubted a promise of page one in 90 days and wanted the first 90 days' deliverables and exit terms in writing (source).

FAQ

How many SEO agencies should I talk to?

Enough to compare like for like; 3 is a common number. One sole trader compared quotes of AUD 600, 1,129.20 and 2,600 a month and found only the dearest listed pages and a timeline (source).

Should I ask for a trial?

Yes: a 30–90 day first phase with fixed deliverables lets you judge delivery before a long contract. 6 of 71 buyers asked about trial, payment, renewal or exit terms up front.

Sources